Freedom Reborn

Community Forums => Polls => Topic started by: Podmark on July 04, 2017, 12:32:11 AM

Title: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Podmark on July 04, 2017, 12:32:11 AM
This week we'll look at Black Canary's Rebirth design as she takes on bigger role in the Green Arrow books:
(http://i.imgur.com/A5HQbGN.jpg)
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Tomato on July 04, 2017, 12:46:30 AM
Ehhhh... I'm sorry, but I'm past the whole fishnets thing for Black Canary. JLU, Young Justice AND all 3 versions of Arrow's Black Canary looked just fine with leggings (though Arrow's outfits are admittedly kinda boring since they're all black) and they're just like... annoying. They're annoying to skin, they're annoying to draw, they're annoying for actual women to wear... and even IRL, most ACTUAL fishnets people wear in public are the semi-translucent ones, not the triangular ones we see here which tend to bunch up and dig into the skin. And heck, at least with a character like Zatanna (the other character who is still depicted in them) you CAN make the case that the old-school magician look is a part of the motif.


Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Glitch Girl on July 04, 2017, 01:57:32 AM
I like the jacket, I like that the top has straps and I like the shoes.  The shorts aren't doing it for me and the fishnets... I know they're traditional but...

I think this works as a rock performance outfit, but not as an actual vigilante outfit. 
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: HarryTrotter on July 04, 2017, 10:56:30 AM
The rest of you can see the picture,right?Does photobucket have something personal against me?  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Tomato on July 04, 2017, 01:24:11 PM
Oh shoot... So, anyone who uses photobucket, you need to start hosting images elsewhere. Photobucket has decided that if you want to use images on another site, you need to pay them $600 for the privilege.

That said, since I can still see it for now:

(http://i.imgur.com/ZFgI8be.jpg)
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: BentonGrey on July 04, 2017, 03:20:52 PM
2: Costumes are stupid, therefore everyone should wear street clothes! :P  Bah.  I know Black Canary's costume is traditionally more street clothes, given her Golden Age origins, but this just doesn't look at all costumeish.  As GG said, she looks like a rockstar, not a superhero.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: spydermann93 on July 04, 2017, 04:13:11 PM
Isn't she a rockstar in the new52/Rebirth? Or did they drop that?
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Ouflah on July 04, 2017, 04:24:19 PM
I'm with Benton here. It doesn't feel 'super' or 'heroic' enough to me.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: BentonGrey on July 04, 2017, 05:37:41 PM
Isn't she a rockstar in the new52/Rebirth? Or did they drop that?

What?  Did they turn her into Dazzler?  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: HarryTrotter on July 04, 2017, 06:09:37 PM
Isn't she a rockstar in the new52/Rebirth? Or did they drop that?
That was DCYou.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Glitch Girl on July 04, 2017, 10:42:37 PM
Isn't she a rockstar in the new52/Rebirth? Or did they drop that?

What?  Did they turn her into Dazzler?  :rolleyes:
More like Joan Jett.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Podmark on July 04, 2017, 10:46:59 PM
Yeah I went with a Dislike too.
It's too much rocker chick and not enough superhero. The top design has some potential but the overall package doesn't do much for me. I don't mind a jacket though.

Spade it's very strange that you can't see my images. Are you getting the standard broken image icon or the Photobuck "Update your account" message?
Either way I'll be changing image hosts soon so that should clear it up.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: UnkoMan on July 29, 2017, 03:09:07 PM
Old thread but.... Is this the version of Black Canary that IS a rocker chick? As in, she is the lead singer of a band?
If so, fishnets make sense. Plus, well I'm just into fishnets... should be ripped. Looks more rock and roll.
Not that this comic was that great. It had an interesting start but then sort of just muddled about and even though there was suppose to be a point to her being in the band, there really wasn't a point to her being in a band.
On the other hand, her band mates were sort of interesting. I think the biggest disappointment was that it had potential that it did not live up to.

Anyhow, I liked this look and the book's art in general. She actually had quite a few outfits in the comic, and I suggest checking it out.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Podmark on July 29, 2017, 03:55:01 PM
Old thread but.... Is this the version of Black Canary that IS a rocker chick? As in, she is the lead singer of a band?

It's not. This design was for the books that came after (designed for Birds of Prey specifically but she was also appearing in Green Arrow). That said it does seem to take some design inspiration from the rocker version.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: daglob on July 29, 2017, 05:26:27 PM
The original was something that we often complain about: it looked like she bought some patterned tights, put on a swimsuit, added a short jacket and buccaneer boots. Oh, and a choker. This worked back when it was created, and it has been around so long that I think it still isn't bad today (but I'm old). But they always seem to have colored the stockings blue, like they weren't really fishnets, just patterned tights. I dunno; maybe that makes sense in a super hero universe. I dislike the boots here in principle: they can't be as practical as some think. I wore boots like that to work in, and while they were protective (steel toe and heavy leather sole), they were a long way from comfortable. I can't see anyone sneaking around in the dark or on a rooftop with them. And I would think that the jacket was impractical for similar reasons: too many things to catch on protrusions, too much shiny stuff to catch the eye of the guy you are sneaking up on, and too much jingly stuff as well. Best to leave something like that alone unless you are riding a motorcycle and your skull is on fire.

Again, it looks like something the designer knew they were not going to have to draw it every month.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Cyber Burn on July 29, 2017, 06:12:07 PM
While I dislike the Costume as a whole, I actually see the logic of the Heavier boots. I agree that they're not much use for stealth and whatnot, but the Canary is a "Street Level" Hero, and is bound to get in fights. When you're being attacked, those boots (Especially the Steel Toe variety) are great for blocking kicks, or for when someone tries to step on your toes.

But I still don't like the Costume.  :P
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Courtnall6 on July 29, 2017, 07:50:15 PM
Not a fan of this one. Really don't like the big clunky combat boots.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: UnkoMan on August 01, 2017, 04:04:39 PM
Ah, my bad then.
But... I still dig Black Canary anyhow. Except for that "Canary Symbol" on the back of the jacket.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: daglob on August 01, 2017, 04:51:08 PM
Ah, my bad then.
But... I still dig Black Canary anyhow. Except for that "Canary Symbol" on the back of the jacket.

Hey, no problem. If we all agreed on everything, how boring would it be? I personally can't stand coconut, and am in a very small minority.
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: Deaths Jester on August 02, 2017, 03:04:33 AM
...but coconuts are so perfect for horse hoove sounds!!!
Title: Re: Costume Rating 132: Black Canary Rebirth
Post by: daglob on August 02, 2017, 04:12:23 AM
The best use I can think of for them...