whats your best and worse skin?

[the_ultimate_evil]

ok Skinners what do you consider the best skin you have ever made and what was the worst and why. and now heres the kickers do the public agree with your choices. :lol:

[Tomato]

Heh, both of mine are renditions of my avatar...

WORST-


Version 1.5-Fugly

Overdone Refl layer, skin is blurred to heck, doesn't fit the mesh AT ALL, black areas look more like gray sweatpants, the face is horrible looking and was made from (I am not kidding) a sprited head.

BEST-



Version 6- Lean and Mean

Body type finally fits what I'd had in mind for the character (the male_basic look was too bulkly) from the beginning, chain mail texture is effective without being over-the-top, and the leaves are no longer cut up sections of a sphere.

[JKCarrier]

Worst: Kamandi. It's just C6's base, with shorts added. Lame!  :thumbdown:

Best: Brainiac. That costume is just soooo wrong, but I loved how it came out:

[Carravaggio]

I have to agree with JKC, that Brainiac is perfect, a silver age villain brought to (electronic) life.
Likewsie for Tomato, the improvement is HUGE, and it's only appropriat ethat his best skin is of his avatar.

For me, counting skins I actually released or plan to release, my best is whatever I'm working on at the moment, as I'm always finding areas to improve in. My favourite design is still the Cardinal, I lucked out on the colours and never looked back.

My worst? Any of the ancient skins I showed in my thread, made before I started posting on FR. They were just kittbashes and recolours of old 256x256 base skins, no seams, no highlights, no actual texturing, just cut and paste colour.

[Podmark]

Literally my worst skin would be one of my earliest like Tien or Darklord or any of the ones from that time that got updated. But honestly I don't consider those my worst. I'm pretty proud of how they came out at the time. My worst would be ones that I grew to dislike quickly after finishing them. Like these:

[spoiler]
Atom Eve was a mess from the start. I couldn't find a mesh I liked and had problems on everything from colouring to line work. She really would have benefited from nifskope.


Bolt just came out looking bland, there's nothing to him.


I hate this skin. It's just ugly, and the undertones are poorly done. I had a great skope set for an update too.
[/spoiler]

Now the best. I'm running off pics of my collected work I had stashed but they don't include some of my newest stuff. I seem to recall really liking my Northstar for example. But here's a few skins I really liked for some reason or another:

[spoiler]
I hated skinning this guy, I had poor ref pics and there was so much minor details for such a minor costume. But I soldiered on and was really happy with the result. Never got the hair quite right but I had a newer skope that was an improvement that never got released.


This was one of the designs I most wanted to skin (I requested a mesh for to 3 separate meshers before I finally got it) and I'm quite happy with the end result. Ironically I can already see ways to improve it.


Always liked this skin. It just came out very nice, which was tricky because the ref pics were hit and miss.


This is one of those was proud at the time skins. I took a really complicated design that I had no right skinning at the time and actually put together something I was quite happy with. However it would benefit so much from the nifskope experience.


These were just like the Hellion skin about, just really happy with their outcome. With nifskope out I look at most of my skins and say "I could do this better now" but these 3 I'm still happy with. No so much the Outsiders one, it's got some blandness to it.


Again see Hellion and Jade.


See Jack of Hearts. Only thing I wasn't big on was the head and I could've fixed that with nifskope.


This was my favorite hair ever. It's just so prefect. Plus the costume came out well. It looked even better on the skope I had made.


A favorite design of mine that I really felt I nailed as a skin. On of my all time favs.
[/spoiler]

But my favorite is [spoiler]
The Ray! This is a favorite of mine for a few reasons. One the hex came out great. Two the skin worked out almost perfectly (there's some mapping/mesh issues that didn't quite come out the way I wanted, mostly the collar). And three at the time that I skined this I was pretty high on the Ray, was even thinking of doing his new costume as well. Nifskope could have improved this one too. [/spoiler]

And now you know :D

[Lunarman]

Hmm, I've not done loads of skinning (although I hope to finally start lots when I get my tablet) but I think that my Lunarman skin is one of my best, either that or Acidnite because the seams and colors just worked on them.




Sadly I've not got my worst skins anymore 'cos I lost them in a computer wipe. But I used to make them on paint using a program called Photo editer to open them and save them as jpegs. They were all just recolors (well colored over) of other peoples skins. I'd find a skin I liked then copy the muscle pattern using different colors and slowly get a similar skin in the color I wanted. They took ages and looked awful, lol. But I learned a lot about paint :P

But so you've got something to laugh at, here's my two worst that I still have.

This is nova, you might see a finished version yet, but I hate this one. She looked cool in my head, but I broke the golden rule and didn't draw a sketch thus certifying that it would be a flop. It's just visually confusing as well as boring and I couldn't get the silver right.


and  my first Lunarman skin is awful too. The thing is I just couldn't face changing my avatar's look and so I left this skin alongside all my better ones in my mod (arg that reminds me, I must release that :( ) but I did get round to changing it, and was very happy with the result. Risk pays off sometimes

Lunarman

[AfghanAnt]

Nova isn't as bad as you think, Lunar.

God, I don't even have my worst skin anymore but I am sure it would either my very first attempt at Afghanant (when he was still Hyperion, the Hyper-man) or Jericho. Actually everything circa 2002 was a mess.

Best skin? I'm not sure...Coipel's Thor or Carey's Cannonball. I really love the way those two came out. I put a lot of love in them both.

[Xenolith]

All of my skins qualify for both categories.   :lol:

[Figure Fan]

All of my skins qualify for both categories.   :lol:

LMFAO!

Ok, here is my worst:

[spoiler]
Chance
[/spoiler]

My best:

[spoiler]
Chance


Abe Sapien (Movie)


Desert Eagle


Ultimate Captain Spud


Ultimate Glitch Girl


Figure Fan

[/spoiler]

[UnfluffyBunny]

ok, out comes the old photobucket album :P
the bad:
[spoiler]



[/spoiler]

the good
[spoiler]




(flats for the monster)
body
limbs
[/spoiler]

[USAgent]

May "good" skins would be considered everyone elses bad skins!!

Here are my by far my 2 worst skins which were done when I just barely learned how to use Photoshop.

Marvel villains Mayhem and Lillith (Dracula's daughter?!?!?)


Ug, I couldnt even match up Mayhem's shirt cuffs with her jacket and ........nice buttons, and are those supposed to be teeth on Lillith's lips?  Man she looks soo evil! :huh:


And some of my skins that "at the time" I thought turned out good (at least to me :lol:)

[spoiler]Daredevil villain Matador
[/spoiler]

[spoiler]Adam X , I liked how his colors turned out, but hated how his "blades" looked (silver triangles)
[/spoiler]

[spoiler]Minor Captain America villain- Wrangler
[/spoiler]

[spoiler]Iron Maiden
[/spoiler]

[spoiler]Mirage- simple costume and no ear pieces but I liked it
[/spoiler]

[Courtnall6]

I took me a while to get to this...a whole lotta stuff to sift through. :wacko:

My worst skin would definitely have to be the unreleased (for obvious reasons) Doc Samson on male_heavy. He was done very early in my skinning career and it is quite horrid.



Here's a bunch of runner-ups for best skin. I could probably add at least 10 more to this pic but I've got stuff to do! :P



And my current top skin would have to be........

[spoiler][/spoiler]

Not what you were expecting I'm sure...but I just love how this one turned out! :cool:

[style]

Ok where can I find that Onslaught and Destroyer mesh/skin at?!!!  :blink:

[UnkoMan]

I think my absolute worst skin was this guy called The Eye. He was basically just a black body suit, with a vaugely Egyptian looking eye on it, and an exposed bald head with similar makeup on one of his eyes. The worst thing ever.

But my best would have to be... Well, I'd say The Phantom Enmity. It just worked so well for me. The skull came out really nicely, and the hood/cape that I made up on the spot shimmered beautifully. The only thing keeping this from being perfect in my eyes is the belt and the gun. The belt could be easily fixed, but I could never figure out how the gun was meshed.

[catastrophe]

Grod and Lex Luthor is insane C6, simply amazing...are they released yet?

and Unko, those Skull Ninjas are awesome...great work!

[The Nemesis]

I hope this doesn't bend the thread to much, but Courtnall you think you could release that picture in some desktop sizes? Thats Effin' sweet!

[Courtnall6]

I hope this doesn't bend the thread to much, but Courtnall you think you could release that picture in some desktop sizes? Thats Effin' sweet!

I would've posted a bigger pic...but Photobucket has a size restriction. <_<

Grod and Lex Luthor is insane C6, simply amazing...are they released yet?

Lex is here http://www.alexff.com/stuffC6-DC.php

Grodd is here http://games.groups.yahoo.com/group/Grenadiermeshes15/files/

Ok where can I find that Onslaught and Destroyer mesh/skin at?!!!  :blink:

Onslaught is unavailable I think...the one in the pic has been slightly updated.

Destroyer is here http://games.groups.yahoo.com/group/Grenadiermeshes15/files/

[aj4life16]

I can not tell you how many orgasms I had on that page with Majestic and Mighty Man.

Are the files in the Majestic download all you need for him? Obviously not including mesh and keyframes.

Or can't you use him yet because it doesn't say where to get the keyframes. Crap.

[zuludelta]

I don't know if they're my "best" skins but these are the ones I had the most fun making:

Black Panther skin for Valandar's Big_Cat_Versatile mesh:


An original character shamelessly ripped off of Jim "Black Belt Jones" Kelly, on a hex of Renegade's RandyRipOff mesh:


An original WWII hero I created for House Quake's shared universe on a hex of Fusion's Captain America_WWII mesh (I would later re-use the same textures for a Sgt. Rock skin):


The original Captain Britain on BeardedInLair's mesh:


Elektra on tommyboy's mesh:


I tended to concentrate more on hex editing as time went on, so the following "favourite skins" aren't really my favourites because of the skin, but because of the work I put in hexing them (this was before NifSkope mind you, so I did everything old-school with a plain old hardcore hexadecimal editor, even some of the re-colouring):

Excalibur's Kylun, on a hex of tommyboy's warrior_versatile mesh:


WildCATs' Grifter, on a hex of TexasJack's pulp_versatile mesh:


Golden Key/Valiant/Acclaim's Turok on a hex of tommyboy's indian_versatile mesh:


Typhoid Mary, not because it's anything special, but because she's one of my favourite villains and I pretty much did a backflip out of sheer joy when tommyboy released his female_versatile mesh and I could finally approximate her appearance in FF form:


I just realized how much mileage and skinning/hexing enjoyment I was able to get out of TJ's and tommy's versatile meshes... thanks for all the work guys!!!

As for my worst skins... it's probably any one of my first dozen or so skins, which were nothing more than poor kitbashes of the stuff on Skindex (anybody remember that old site?).

EDIT: credited pulp_versatile mesh to TexasJack

[aj4life16]

I use That Grifter.  :wub:

Any chance I could get the Turok?

[tommyboy]

I feel I should mention that Pulp_versatile wasn't one of mine. I think TexasJack deserves the kudos for that one.
My worst skins are too many to choose from. Pick any mesh I've made, you'll find one,  :D
I haven't made my best skin yet, as I'm still on the learning curve...

[GGiant]

I feel I should mention that Pulp_versatile wasn't one of mine. I think TexasJack deserves the kudos for that one.
My worst skins are too many to choose from. Pick any mesh I've made, you'll find one,  :D
I haven't made my best skin yet, as I'm still on the learning curve...

Hank Pym Skin is the best!

[detourne_me]

you're MUA Hulk skins are legit Tommy!
so are ronin and the widow skins

[UnfluffyBunny]

i'm really shocked not to see lobo in C6's pic @_@

[zuludelta]

I feel I should mention that Pulp_versatile wasn't one of mine. I think TexasJack deserves the kudos for that one.

:doh: ah, I forgot that one, probably because of the "_versatile" naming convention that you used on your warrior_versatile and female_versatile meshes.

Any chance I could get the Turok?

Hmmm... it might be in one of my yahoo groups (sorry, I don't really keep track of what's out there anymore), or you could ask if anybody else has it. I lost most of my FF stuff in a hard drive crash a year ago. Good luck finding it!

[Xenolith]

I feel I should mention that Pulp_versatile wasn't one of mine. I think TexasJack deserves the kudos for that one.
My worst skins are too many to choose from. Pick any mesh I've made, you'll find one,  :D
I haven't made my best skin yet, as I'm still on the learning curve...

From what I've seen lately, you are making great progress in your skinning.   :thumbup:  Not that your old ones were bad, but your new ones are very nice.

[the_ultimate_evil]

i started this thread os i guess i should really post mine, shamefully pinched the layout design

what i believe to be my worst



and my best

[Mystik]

where can i find that joker

[GGiant]

That's the best Venom skin I have ever seen! :o

[catastrophe]

its probably not my worst but its the most idiotic skin and idea i've ever had for a character.

The Purple Penguin



My best are probably

Doctor Neutrino or Rotten Tomato